Where prayer & sweets meet

Sweet
Treats,
Beautifully
Made.

A home bakery turning out custom cakes, royal icing cookies, cupcakes and cake pops — handmade to order in Hamlet, Indiana.

Place an OrderSee the Work
Pink frosted birthday cake with gold number balloons, raspberries and white daisies
Boxed cookies and cupcakes with storybook character icing transfers and pink bows
Chocolate-dipped strawberries in paper cones with flag picks and gold accents
  • Custom Cakes
  • Royal Icing Cookies
  • Cake Pops
  • Cupcakes
  • Dipped Strawberries
  • Gift Boxes
  • Zucchini Bread
  • Baby Showers
  • Birthdays

What’s Baking

The Menu

Everything is made to order. Tell me what you’re celebrating and we’ll build the rest around it.

  1. 01

    Custom Cakes

    Personalized cakes for birthdays, showers, and milestone celebrations — tiered, sculpted, themed, or simply elegant.

    Two-tier naked cake ringed with rosemary and topped with gingerbread deer
  2. 02

    Decorated Cookies

    Hand-decorated cookies finished with smooth, vibrant royal icing in the colors and patterns your event calls for.

    Boxed cookies and cupcakes with storybook character icing transfers and pink bows
  3. 03

    Cupcakes & Cake Pops

    Frosted cupcakes and handmade cake pops by the dozen, themed to your party or kept classic and simple.

    Berry frosted cupcakes topped with blueberries and fresh basil leaves
  4. 04

    Sweet Treats & Desserts

    Chocolate-dipped strawberries, watercolor lollipops, homemade breads like zucchini bread, and a rotating lineup of confections.

    Chocolate-dipped strawberries in paper cones with flag picks and gold accents
  5. 05

    Event & Occasion Orders

    Full dessert spreads tailored to your event — baby showers, birthdays, weddings, and everything in between. Order in advance.

    White frosted cupcakes on a dessert table beneath a green balloon garland
Single-tier cake in textured white buttercream crowned with fresh roses and eucalyptus

Buttercream & fresh florals

Our Story

Hi there,
Sugary Friends!

Welcome to Tiffany's Sugar Shack — a passion-driven home bakery in Hamlet, Indiana, dedicated to making gorgeous, delicious celebration treats. From tiered custom cakes and frosted cupcakes to cake pops and smooth royal icing cookies, everything here is made with heart.

Each creation is handcrafted with care, featuring beautiful textures and intricate designs perfect for celebrations like baby showers, birthdays, and everyday indulgences.

Whether you’re after a show-stopping birthday cake, a box of decorated cookies, or a tray of sweet treats for the table, Tiffany's Sugar Shack brings creativity and love to every bite — straight from our kitchen to your hands.

Made

To order

Baked

At home

Served

Hamlet, IN

Where prayer
& sweets meet

From the Kitchen

Recent Work

View the full gallery →
Castle-themed first birthday cake in pink and blue with a fondant crown topper
Berry frosted cupcakes topped with blueberries and fresh basil leaves
Two-tier naked cake ringed with rosemary and topped with gingerbread deer
Boxed cupcakes decorated with ballpark mascots, letters and baseball stitching
Pink frosted birthday cake with gold number balloons, raspberries and white daisies
Absolutely delicious treats every time!

Instagram Follower

Let’s Bake Something

Tell me what
you’re celebrating.

Every order starts with a conversation — your date, your theme, your flavors. Send the details and I’ll take it from there.

Start Your Order